The romance between characters Broderick Adams and Ophelia Kelly is noted for its "super high heat level" and "fantastic chemistry".

While it is linked to Reid's All the King's Men duet, reviewers mention it can be enjoyed as a standalone without prior knowledge of the main series. Reader Perspectives

“Songbird is about two lonely people who spend a magical evening together one Christmas Eve, it was a sweet story and I really liked both of the main characters but it just felt a little rushed and unfinished.” Feeling Fictional · 6 years ago

Some reviewers felt the novella format made the story feel a bit short, leaving them wanting more of the characters' future.

Reviews of by Penny Reid and L.H. Cosway generally praise it as a sweet, high-chemistry holiday novella, though some readers find it feels slightly rushed or unfinished . Critical Summary

“Broderick Adams doesn't mind his solitude, until she walks in. Ophelia Kelly sings to heal her heart, but has no idea he's listening.” Celebrity Readers · 4 years ago

Review: Christmas in the City - Anthology - Feeling Fictional

Critics describe the story as having "magical" Christmas vibes set in Dublin.