: A 900-year-old witch named Patrick runs the game. Bobby loses 25 years trying to escape his wheelchair, and Dean loses most of his life trying to win them back, turning into an old man .
In this episode, Sam and Dean investigate a town where a wishing well at a restaurant called actually makes wishes come true, leading to chaotic results.
: Sam ultimately wins the game to save Dean, who was suffering a heart attack due to old age. Other Shows with "Wishful Thinking" S5E7
: Highlights include a giant, depressed, alcoholic Bigfoot , an invisible man spying on women in a locker room, and a little girl’s teddy bear coming to life as a "bipolar" existentialist.
: The brothers discover a Babylonian cursed coin—the "Seed of Chaos"—at the bottom of the well.