[s1e5] Covention Review

Critics at The Convention Collective and other outlets describe the show as "campy, over the top, and silly," but ultimately a "fun, riveting" experience that hits the right dramatic notes.

A notable "weird and awkward" moment frequently mentioned is a confrontation involving a skateboard and an air-dropped book, which some felt was shoehorned in but added to the show's eccentric charm. [S1E5] Covention

The episode is generally well-received for its choreography and "cool power use," with some reviewers giving it a solid 8.5/10 , noting that it sets the stage for a high-stakes second half of the season. Critics at The Convention Collective and other outlets

Reviewers find the focus on Dave's double life particularly riveting. In this episode, he attends a firefighters' convention (the "stick" of his regular life) while the narrative leans heavily into his dangerous nature as an arsonist and habitual cheater. Reviewers find the focus on Dave's double life

For a deeper dive into the episode's themes and character breakdowns, watch this spoiler review: Smoke Episode 5 Review | Recap & Breakdown | Apple TV+ Steve Varley Show YouTube• Jul 17, 2025 Smoke Episode 5 Review | Recap & Breakdown | Apple TV+

For of Smoke , titled "Size Matters," reviews highlight a shift into high-octane camp and character drama as the series hits its halfway point. Critics often compare the show's tone to Rescue Me , featuring a cast of "despicable but entertaining" characters. Key Review Highlights