Loading
“I think this episode is comparable to season 2: mostly realistic, emphasizing character, and disappointingly short on laugh-out-loud humor.” Me Blog Write Good · 4 years ago
It holds a 7.4/10 on IMDb . While not reaching the heights of classic episodes like "Duffless," it is frequently ranked as one of the best in Season 11 for its emotional attempt. Community Perspectives [S11E18] Days of Wine and D'Ohses
“Aside from that and the fact that Dan Castellaneta (the voice of Homer) and his wife wrote it, there's little else to say about this episode. Like many this season, it's fairly mediocre, with a few laughs along the way but nothing to get too worked up about...” The Real Gentlemen of Leisure · 16 years ago “I think this episode is comparable to season
Some argue that "Sober Barney" is inherently less funny or "boring" compared to his classic "town drunk" persona. Reviewers at Dead Homer Society and Review Nebula find the tone inconsistent, with Homer's "Jerkass" behavior—petulantly resenting his friend's sobriety—being a major point of irritation. Like many this season, it's fairly mediocre, with
Critics praise the "warm-hearted" plotting and the rare bit of character growth for Barney, which actually stuck for several seasons. The B-plot, involving Bart and Lisa's quest for a phone book cover photo, is considered a clever tie-in that culminates in a surprisingly competent action climax.
(Season 11, Episode 18) is often cited as a "diamond in the rough" of the Mike Scully era for attempting genuine character development. It famously depicts Barney Gumble finally deciding to sober up after seeing a humiliating video of his birthday party. Critics' Consensus