Consignment Stores That Buy Clothes Apr 2026

“Buffalo Exchange is very picky! I made $40 after selling like 10 pieces... My sister went with 3 bags full of stuff to sell and they took nothing.” Reddit · r/sandiego · 8 years ago

Resale shoppers and sellers often have strong opinions on the process: “I took 1500 and they'd sell at 400 or 500$.” Reddit · r/Winnipeg · 3 years ago

: The go-to for luxury designer goods, though it is a true consignment model where you wait for the item to sell before getting paid. 💡 Key Differences: Buy-Out vs. Consignment Buy-Out (e.g., Buffalo Exchange) True Consignment (e.g., The RealReal) Payment Time Immediate (cash or credit on the spot) After the item sells Payout Amount Lower (typically 30–35% cash) Higher (typically 40–70% of sale price) Risk Store takes the risk of it not selling You take the risk; if it doesn't sell, you get nothing Community Experiences consignment stores that buy clothes

Selling your clothes to a consignment or resale store is a fast way to clear space and get paid, but the experience varies wildly based on the store's "buy" model. Popular Resale & Consignment Stores

: Known for being very picky and focusing on a specific, often "trendy" or "retro" aesthetic. They typically offer 30% cash or 50% store credit of the projected selling price on the spot. “Buffalo Exchange is very picky

: Best for "mall brands" like Zara, H&M, and Gap, specifically targeting teens and people in their early 20s.

: Focuses on a mix of designer, mid-range (like Theory or Madewell), and current high-street fashion. 💡 Key Differences: Buy-Out vs

: Often considered faster and sometimes less selective than Plato’s Closet for everyday fashion.