Taking the case with extreme seriousness, Finn and Jake adopt hard-boiled detective personas. Their investigation leads them to:

: True to her nature, LSP's "tragedy" is revealed to be a dramatic misunderstanding born from her own intense infatuation. Technical Credits Writers/Storyboarders : Somvilay Xayaphone and Luke Pearson.

: They find LSP’s trashed room and discover what Finn believes is blood (which BMO later identifies as tomato sauce).

: They track down the suspicious "Pete," only to realize there are two different Petes. They eventually corner a pizza delivery boy named Pete.

In (Season 5, Episode 25), Finn and Jake trade their usual heroics for a gritty, noir-style police investigation to solve a "crime" against Lumpy Space Princess (LSP). Plot Summary

: They interrogate a clerk named Ann, who provides an overly detailed history of Pete Sassafras, a man prone to nosebleeds.

: The episode is a tribute to crime dramas like Law & Order and The Wire , complete with dun-dun sound effects and noir lighting.