: Critics agree that Jon Bernthal is the show's strongest asset, bringing a muted magnetism and vulnerability to the role of Julian Kaye that differentiates him from Richard Gere's original version.
The series premiere of American Gigolo (2022) generally received from critics. While Jon Bernthal’s "soulful" and "captivating" lead performance is widely praised, reviewers noted that the episode suffers from convoluted plotting and an over-reliance on flashbacks . Critical Consensus American.Gigolo.S01E01.WEBRip.x264-ION10
: Reviewers at IGN noted that the series trades the "steaminess" of the 1980 film for a darker, more dreary "soapy redemption story" focused on past trauma and a central murder mystery. : Critics agree that Jon Bernthal is the
: Rosie O’Donnell’s performance as Detective Joan Sunday is highlighted as a source of much-needed "levity and energy". Episode Highlights & Score "American Gigolo" Pilot (TV Episode 2022) - IMDb Critical Consensus : Reviewers at IGN noted that
: The pilot is often described as "scatterbrained" and "heavy-handed," with some critics at Rotten Tomatoes noting that the "choppy pacing" and "slow burn" may test viewers' patience.